Buyer’s Guide Overview for IT Managers

The Managed IT Services Buyer’s Guide for IT Managers is a comprehensive resource designed to assist IT managers in selecting the right managed service provider (MSP) for their organization's IT needs. The guide offers a framework to identify requirements, evaluate service providers, and compare costs and contract terms to make informed decisions. It emphasizes the importance of a proactive IT partnership that goes beyond day-to-day support to include strategic IT planning, budgeting, and technology roadmapping. Key topics covered include 24/7 remote monitoring and management, service desk support, account management, asset management, network and security monitoring, backup management, preventative maintenance, and procurement strategies.

The guide also addresses common reasons to switch IT providers, such as poor communication, slow response times, recurring issues, lack of proactivity, and inadequate security focus. It provides a list of critical questions to ask potential IT partners to ensure they have robust processes, proactive support, and a clear understanding of data protection and compliance requirements. The guide underscores the value of working in partnership with an MSP that offers scalable support, a wide skill set, and regular strategic reviews.

Additional sections cover cyber security awareness training, phishing simulation tests, and the importance of ongoing education to mitigate cyber threats. The guide also highlights the onboarding process for new clients, from initial assessment to training and strategic reviews, ensuring a smooth transition and successful long-term partnership. Overall, the guide aims to help IT managers bridge knowledge gaps, reduce decision risk, and streamline IT procurement tailored to their organization's size, growth stage, and industry regulations.

Relevant Managed IT Services

The Managed IT Services Buyer's Guide for IT Managers provides a detailed summary of managed IT services tailored specifically for IT managers. Key service categories include Service Desk remote support with a first-time fix policy, dedicated account management with regular strategic reviews and technology roadmapping, asset management through remote monitoring and management (RMM) platforms, and 24/7 remote monitoring and management of devices and network resources to proactively prevent issues. Network and security monitoring with tailored alert thresholds, backup management using industry-leading providers, and preventative maintenance such as security updates and hardware reviews are also core components. The guide emphasizes the importance of IT strategy support, including budgeting and technology roadmaps aligned with business goals. Cybersecurity services cover staff training, phishing simulations, endpoint protection, and compliance with data protection regulations. Additionally, the guide highlights the value of a structured onboarding process and a collaborative partnership model that complements in-house IT teams, offering scalable support and access to a broad skill set. These services collectively aim to provide proactive support, cost savings, scalability, and enhanced operational efficiency, addressing the unique workflows, compliance needs, and budget considerations of IT managers. (primaryt.co.uk)

Key Selection Criteria

• Responsiveness and customer support: MSPs should meet response time requirements, deliver service per SLA, and act as true partners treating your business as their own.

• Ease of onboarding: MSPs must have proven, smooth onboarding processes with dedicated teams to minimize transition pain.

• Technical and business expertise: Evaluate MSPs for technical skills relevant to your technology stack and understanding of your business goals.

• Operational excellence: MSPs should have mature, documented processes and high operational maturity scores (e.g., OML above 4.0).

• Automation and quality assurance: MSPs should use automation for patch management, backups, security audits, and help desk tasks to improve efficiency and reduce errors.

• Deep security expertise: MSPs must have certified security experts (e.g., CISSPs), SOC 2 compliance, and integrated security services.

• Customer experience: MSPs should demonstrate high customer satisfaction with metrics like Net Promoter Score and Customer Effort Score.

• Governance and regulatory compliance: MSPs should help design and maintain governance standards and assist with compliance to regulations such as HIPAA, PCI, GDPR.

• Proactive monitoring and issue prevention: MSPs should offer 24/7 monitoring, automated alerts, and self-healing technologies to prevent downtime.

• Tailored support and scalability: MSPs must customize services to your business size, industry, and growth stage, with scalable solutions.

• Cloud and infrastructure expertise: MSPs should have strong cloud migration, hybrid environment management, and infrastructure optimization skills.

• Disaster recovery and business continuity: MSPs must have robust, tested disaster recovery plans and fast restoration capabilities.

• Comprehensive service offerings: MSPs should provide patch management, equipment procurement, security, backup, help desk, remote management, and compliance services.

• Strategic planning and IT roadmap support: MSPs should assist with technology roadmaps, budgeting, and regular strategic reviews aligned with business objectives.

• Transparent contract terms and exit plans: MSPs should provide clarity on contract length, SLAs, notice periods, and exit procedures.

Typical Pricing Models

• Flat-rate pricing: Fixed monthly fee for a defined set of services, providing predictable costs and budgeting ease.

• Tiered pricing: Multiple service tiers with varying support levels and features, allowing choice based on needs and budget.

• Per-device/per-user pricing: Charges based on number of devices or users, scalable for organizations of all sizes.

• On-demand pricing: Pay only for selected individual services, offering flexibility but potentially higher costs.

• Value-based pricing: Pricing based on value delivered to the client, such as improved uptime or enhanced security.

• Monitoring-only pricing: Basic network monitoring and alerting services, often used to support an internal IT department.

• A la carte pricing: Clients select specific services to build a customized offering, allowing for high customization.

Typical Cost Range: Managed IT services for IT managers typically range from $1,500 to $10,000+ per month depending on business size and complexity. Smaller businesses often pay between $1,500 and $3,000 per month for basic services like IT support, cybersecurity, and data backup. Mid-sized businesses with more complex needs usually pay $3,000 to $5,000 per month. Large enterprises with advanced requirements and 24/7 support generally pay $10,000 or more per month. Pricing models vary, including flat-rate, hourly, per-device, and per-user pricing, with costs ranging from $50 to $400 per user per month or $15 to $500 per device per month depending on the service level and device type. This range reflects the diversity of IT needs and compliance requirements faced by IT managers in different organizations.

Vendor Evaluation Checklist

Managed IT Services Vendor Evaluation Checklist for IT Managers

1. Understand Your Organization’s IT Needs

• Identify IT functions needing support (daily operations, end-user support, cloud services, cybersecurity).

• Consider business size and scope.

• Evaluate industry-specific compliance requirements (e.g., HIPAA, PCI DSS).

2. Check Provider Credentials and Expertise

• Years in business.

• Experience with similar-sized businesses and industries.

• Availability of client testimonials and references.

• Technical certifications and vendor partnerships.

3. Examine Service Level Agreements (SLAs)

• Clear definition of SLAs and termination clauses.

• Contract coverage and duration.

• Insurance coverage details.

4. Evaluate Support and Monitoring Capabilities

• 24/7 support availability.

• Dedicated support/account manager.

• Response times and guaranteed uptime.

5. Assess IT Security and Disaster Recovery

• Security awareness training for employees.

• Documented cybersecurity plans.

• Physical and network security protocols.

• Frequency of system updates and patches.

• Average recovery time (MTTR) and tested disaster recovery plan.

6. Review Transition and Cloud Migration Support

• Cloud migration and transition services.

• Ability to migrate data and systems.

• Ongoing cloud data management and scalability.

7. Consider Infrastructure and Technical Requirements

• High availability and redundancy.

• Backup solutions and disaster recovery planning.

• Network security measures (firewalls, anti-malware, encryption).

• Use of secure and reliable data centers.

8. Confirm Compliance and Reporting

• Assistance with regulatory compliance.

• Regular performance reviews.

• Detailed reporting and analytics.

9. Evaluate Costs and Scalability

• Transparent and flexible pricing models.

• Customizable services.

• Scalability to grow with your business.

10. Assess Vendor Reputation and Reliability

• Customer reviews and testimonials.

• Relevant case studies.

• Years of experience.

• Certifications and technology partnerships.

11. Understand Contract Terms and Exit Strategy

• Contract length and commitment.

• Renewal and termination clauses.

• Data retrieval and exit plan.

12. Additional Considerations

• Proactive vs. reactive support approach.

• Communication quality and responsiveness.

• Training availability for your staff.

• Alignment with your long-term IT strategy and business goals.

This checklist is synthesized from multiple expert Managed IT Services buyer’s guides tailored for IT managers, ensuring a comprehensive evaluation framework to reduce risk and select the optimal managed IT services provider. (Dataprise, The KR Group, Outsource Solutions Group, Align, Primary Technology PDF)

Risk Management Tips

When selecting managed IT services, IT managers should focus on several key risk management strategies: conduct thorough due diligence on providers including financial stability and security practices; establish clear service level agreements (SLAs) and contracts detailing responsibilities, performance metrics, and exit strategies; implement robust security measures such as encryption, access controls, multi-factor authentication, and regular audits; maintain continuous monitoring and auditing of service quality and compliance; develop a vendor exit strategy to avoid lock-in; ensure transparency and maintain control and visibility over IT operations; verify compliance with industry regulations (e.g., GDPR, HIPAA, PCI DSS); foster strong collaboration and communication with providers; apply Zero Trust security principles and least privilege access; maintain offsite backups and logs for recovery and forensics; and include MSPs in incident response and business continuity planning with clear protocols. These practices help mitigate risks like data breaches, service outages, compliance failures, and vendor dependency, ensuring secure and reliable managed IT services. (svitla.com, compassitc.com, cisa.gov)

Compliance Considerations

• HIPAA (Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act) for healthcare data protection

• CMMC (Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification) for defense-related contracts

• ISO 27001 for information security management systems

• SOC 2 for security, availability, processing integrity, confidentiality, and privacy of customer data

• NIST 800-171 for safeguarding Controlled Unclassified Information (CUI) in nonfederal systems

• PCI DSS (Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard) for payment data security

• FERPA (Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act) for education sector data privacy

• Regular risk assessments and continuous monitoring for compliance maintenance

• Use of compliance automation tools for documentation and evidence management

• Alignment with client-specific compliance frameworks and contractual obligations

• Third-party audits and certifications for compliance validation

Operational Challenges

IT managers face multiple operational and technical challenges that shape their managed IT services vendor needs. Key challenges include ensuring prompt and effective support in increasingly remote work environments to avoid costly downtime; overcoming MSPs' insufficient technical expertise that can prolong outages; managing resource constraints during cloud migrations; addressing cybersecurity threats with proactive maintenance, monitoring, and disaster recovery strategies; and ensuring compatibility between new services and existing IT infrastructure to avoid costly misalignments. Additionally, IT managers must mitigate risks related to vendor lock-in, unclear communication, scaling services with business growth, managing unforeseen costs, and maintaining high service quality. Effective vendor management is critical to reduce risks of operational disruptions, compliance failures, and data breaches. These challenges necessitate partnering with MSPs that offer technical expertise, scalable and flexible services, transparent SLAs, robust security frameworks, and strong communication to align IT operations with business goals and compliance requirements.

IT Provider Comparison

The Managed IT Services Buyer’s Guide for IT Managers emphasizes evaluating MSPs on responsiveness, onboarding ease, technical and business expertise, operational excellence, security capabilities, customer experience, and compliance support. Key comparisons include MSPs' ability to manage Microsoft and cloud platforms, provide proactive 24/7 monitoring, automation, and self-healing technologies, and maintain certifications like SOC 2. Pricing models vary from per-device to value-based, with a focus on aligning services to business goals and regulatory requirements. IT managers are advised to assess MSPs through detailed questions on SLAs, security, and customer satisfaction, viewing MSPs as strategic partners rather than vendors. (Sources: logically.com, primaryt.co.uk, cynet.com, tealtech.com)

Recommended Providers

• Cynet

• Logically

• Ntiva

• Primary Technology

• Zluri

• ScienceSoft

• Dataprise

• Burwood Group

• Electric

• All Covered

Actionable Recommendations

• Develop a clear IT strategy aligned with business goals, including budgeting for short- and long-term technology investments.

• Engage in regular strategic reviews with your managed IT service provider (MSP), ideally every six months, to ensure IT services meet evolving needs.

• Ensure your MSP provides proactive 24/7 monitoring, preventative maintenance, and quick response times to minimize downtime.

• Confirm assignment of a dedicated account manager from your MSP for consistent communication and IT strategy support.

• Include an exit plan in your MSP contract to facilitate smooth transitions if changing providers.

• Prioritize cybersecurity by implementing regular staff training, phishing simulations, and comprehensive security measures.

• Collaborate with your MSP on hardware and software procurement and replacement strategies to optimize costs and operational continuity.

• Foster a partnership approach where your MSP complements and enhances your in-house IT staff’s capabilities.

• Ask potential MSPs detailed questions about their issue resolution processes, security practices, team expertise, and customer references.

• Manage change carefully during onboarding, supporting employees as they adapt to new IT systems and processes.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What is the process for dealing with IT issues that we report?

2. How do you minimize the number of IT issues proactively?

3. What benefits can we expect from using your managed IT services?

4. Can you tell us about your team and who will be working with us?

5. How is my data protected under your managed IT services?

6. Is there training to ensure my staff get the most out of this investment?

7. Are there metrics to assess speed, reliability, and overall performance of your services?

8. How does your team stay current with new technology developments and trends?

9. Can you provide customer references and access to existing customers?

10. What does proactive service mean to you?

11. Do you offer 24/7 monitoring and support?

12. How quickly can an on-site technician be dispatched?

13. Do you offer cybersecurity services and what do they cover?

14. Do you assist with regulatory compliance and audit preparation?

15. How do you handle data backup and disaster recovery?

16. What are your pay structure and contract terms?

17. Do you offer any additional services such as consulting or training?

18. Can you provide a detailed breakdown of the services and fees included in your contract?

19. What certifications do your technicians hold?

20. How do you measure customer satisfaction and service quality?

Service Level Agreement Details

Service Level Agreements (SLAs) in managed IT services for IT managers are formal contracts that define the service standards a managed IT provider promises to deliver. Typical SLAs include coverage of services and devices, response times, estimated resolution times, installation and setup, technical support availability (e.g., 24/7/365 or business hours), incident reporting, escalation procedures, emergency support, automated monitoring, support methods (online chat, phone, onsite), reporting, performance metrics like uptime, and client responsibilities. SLAs also detail the service request ticketing process, including points of contact, problem synopsis, initial response and evaluation, status updates, escalation steps, resolution documentation, and feedback mechanisms. These agreements establish clear expectations, accountability, and consistent service reliability, helping IT managers optimize uptime and productivity. Absence of SLAs in contracts can indicate a lack of transparency from the provider. (KelserCorp)

Key Security Features

• Advanced Threat Intelligence: Leveraging data and analytics to identify potential security threats proactively.

• Incident Response Planning: Comprehensive strategies to quickly address and mitigate security breaches.

• Compliance Management: Ensuring adherence to industry regulations and standards like GDPR, HIPAA, PCI-DSS.

• Regular Security Assessments and Audits: Frequent reviews to identify security gaps and ensure compliance.

• Real-Time Analytics and Reporting: Continuous monitoring and insights into vulnerabilities and threats.

• Managed Detection and Response (MDR): Proactive threat hunting, detection, and response combining human expertise and technology.

• Security Information and Event Management (SIEM): Collecting and analyzing security events for early breach detection.

• Managed Firewall Services: Continuous network traffic monitoring and threat response.

• Endpoint Protection: Securing devices with encryption, antivirus, and data loss prevention.

• Vulnerability Management: Identifying, classifying, and addressing IT environment vulnerabilities including patch management.

• Identity and Access Management (IAM): Controlling user access to critical systems to prevent unauthorized access.

• Proactive Monitoring and Threat Detection: 24/7 surveillance to identify and mitigate threats before damage occurs.

• Access to IT Expertise: Leveraging certified security professionals and virtual Chief Information Security Officers (vCISO).

• Advanced Security Tools: Firewalls, intrusion detection systems, encryption technologies, antivirus software.

• Data Backup and Disaster Recovery: Regular backups and tailored recovery plans to ensure business continuity.

• Help Desk Support with Advanced Escalation: 24/7 technical assistance with escalation for complex issues.

• Physical and Environmental Protection: Access controls, surveillance, environmental controls to protect physical assets.

• Unified Threat Management (UTM) and Web Application Firewalls: Integrated security layers for network and applications.

• DDoS Mitigation and Network-based Firewalls: Protection against denial-of-service attacks and network intrusions.

• Threat Intelligence and Predictive Analytics: Monitoring, reporting, and reputation monitoring to anticipate threats.

• Incident Analysis and Malware Detection and Removal: Security information and event management for incident response.

Integration Support

• Microsoft platforms (e.g., Microsoft 365, Windows Server)

• Google platforms (e.g., Google Workspace)

• Dell hardware

• HP hardware

• Cisco networking equipment

• Remote Monitoring and Management (RMM) tools

• Service Desk and ticketing systems

• Backup management solutions from industry-leading providers

• Cybersecurity tools including phishing simulation and endpoint detection software

Provider Performance Metrics

• Monthly recurring revenue rate

• Profit Margins

• Customer lifetime value (CLV)

• Revenue growth

• Average resolution time (ticket resolution)

• First contact resolution rate (FCR)

• System uptime

• Resource utilization

• Customer satisfaction (CSAT)

• Net promoter score (NPS)

• Customer retention rate

• Employee satisfaction

• Number of security incidents

• Mean time to detect (MTTD)

• Compliance levels

• Total Recurring Revenue Growth

• Top-Line (Net-New) Recurring Revenue Growth

• Total Bookings Revenue Growth (Total Contract Value Growth)

• Base Revenue Growth

• Gross Margin

• Operating Income (Net Operating Income/Net Profit)

• Recurring Revenue Retention Rate

• Client Retention Rate

• Ticket resolution time

• First Call Resolution (FCR)

• Customer Satisfaction (CSAT)

• Network uptime

• Network latency

• Network utilization

• Server uptime

• Downtime incidents

• Mean Time Between Failures (MTBF)

• Patch management compliance

• Compliance score

• Backup success rate

• Recovery Time Objective (RTO)

• Recovery Point Objective (RPO)

• IT budget variance

• Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)

• IT Return on Investment (ROI)

• Workstation downtime

• Application performance

• User adoption rates

• Project timelines

• Project budget adherence

• Scope creep

• Cost of goods sold (COGS)

• Recurring revenue rate

• Gross profitability

• Average revenue per user (ARPU)

• Client contribution

• Earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization (EBITDA)

• Sales performance

• Product margin

• Average first response time

• Resource/agent utilization rate

• Opened/closed tickets ratio

• Aggregate service desk performance

• Employee satisfaction (repeated)

• Satisfaction rating

• Customer churn rate

• SLA compliance rate

• Customer lifetime value (repeated)

• Customer efficiency

Scalability Options

• Scalable support that allows IT projects to scale up by working with a technical team and account manager already familiar with the organization.

• Flexible managed IT services that can scale up or down as business needs change, accommodating growth or reduction in IT demands.

• Subscription-based pricing models that reflect the level of technology usage, providing budget-friendly scalability.

• Co-managed IT support that complements in-house IT staff, allowing them to focus on core tasks while scaling support through the MSP.

• Technology roadmaps developed by the MSP to plan IT investments and support scaling over 2-3 years.

• Regular strategic reviews (recommended every 6 months) with the MSP to adjust services and support as the organization grows or changes.

• Access to a wide skill set and additional staff from the MSP to handle increased or complex IT needs without hiring internally.

• Cloud and multi-cloud management services that enable scalable infrastructure and applications, supporting business growth and complexity.

• Flexible contract terms that allow adding or removing service offerings based on evolving business needs.

• Use of remote monitoring and management platforms (RMM) to maintain asset registers and proactively manage IT infrastructure as it scales.

Migration Assistance

Managed IT service providers (MSPs) support system and data migration through a structured transition process designed to minimize disruption and ensure business continuity. This process typically includes an initial assessment to identify IT goals, system performance, and gaps, followed by designing a detailed transition plan with clear roles, responsibilities, milestones, and timelines. Key migration assistance features involve data migration with full backups, access migration reviewing and modifying access rights, component migration evaluating applications and software to be moved, and process changes for support and escalation procedures. MSPs execute the transition using phased rollouts or full-scale migrations, prioritizing goals such as efficiency, cost reduction, or security enhancement. They handle hardware installations, software upgrades, and coordinate with vendors, scheduling migrations during low-traffic periods to minimize downtime. Testing and validation ensure all systems and applications function correctly, meet performance benchmarks, and comply with security standards. Post-transition, MSPs provide continuous optimization, including performance monitoring, updates, security assessments, scalability adjustments, and IT budget optimization. Throughout, MSPs perform the heavy lifting while the internal IT team provides oversight, ensuring a smooth, secure, and hassle-free migration experience for IT managers transitioning to managed IT services. (https://www.itjones.com/blogs/transitioning-to-managed-it-services-a-step-by-step-guide)

Support Models

• 24/7 remote monitoring and support

• On-site support available with varying response times

• Hybrid support models combining remote and on-site assistance

• Dedicated account managers or dedicated support teams

• Help desk support with in-house or outsourced staffing

• Proactive support including continuous network and cybersecurity monitoring

• Reactive support for incident response and troubleshooting

• Co-managed IT services partnering with internal IT staff

• Support available on weekends and holidays

• Service Level Agreements (SLAs) defining response and resolution times

Regional Availability

• United Kingdom

Contract Length Options

• Month-to-month

• 1 year

• 3 years

• 5 years

Implementation Time Estimate: The overall timeline for implementing managed IT services typically ranges from a few weeks to several months. This depends on the complexity of the project, the size of the organization, the readiness of the IT infrastructure, and the specific requirements involved. The process includes stages such as assessing the current IT environment, planning and designing the solution, actual implementation, testing, and the transition phase where the organization fully adopts the services.

Trial Period: Integrated Computer Services, Inc. offers a 60-day free trial period for their managed IT services. During this trial, organizations have access to unlimited remote and on-site technical support, guaranteed response times (30 minutes or less for emergencies), disaster recovery management, proactive IT computer and server health monitoring, and managed security services including multifactor authentication, anti-phishing training, next-gen anti-malware, firewall management, and network risk assessments. The trial is no obligation, and customers can cancel anytime during the 60 days if not satisfied.

Related Blog Posts

• Managed IT Services Buyer’s Guide for Operational Leaders

• Managed IT Services Buyer’s Guide for Retail Chain Managers